Profitable but Cash-Strapped: A Contractor’s Wake-Up Call
Key Highlights
- Accrual-basis revenue may be reported before customers pay, so profit does not necessarily mean cash is available
- Retainage and slow-paying receivables can delay collections; forecast them based on contract terms and realistic payment timing
- Treat payroll tax funds, delayed estimated payments, and new-project deposits used to finance existing work as warning signs that call for prompt review.
In the construction industry, it is not unusual to hear owners say they are unable to pay their tax bill because they do not have enough cash. As an accountant specializing in tax preparation, planning, and projections for contractors, I approach a tax bill with two questions: What does the business owe, and where will the cash come from? A profitable income statement answers neither question completely. Contractors need a plan that connects reported earnings, customer collections, operating commitments, and taxes.
Consider a contractor generating $3 million in annual revenue and reporting $750,000 in profit. Suppose the estimated income tax obligation is $225,000. That figure is illustrative, not a universal tax rate or a completed tax projection. Even with substantial reported profit, the contractor may lack the cash to make the payment.
The central lesson is simple: profit does not equal cash. An inability to pay taxes may signal a cash management problem rather than a lack of profitability.
Understand the Gap Between Earnings and Collections
Under accrual accounting, revenue can appear on the income statement before the customer pays. A contractor may complete work, issue an invoice, and report revenue while still waiting for the money. The financial statements are not necessarily wrong; they may be showing earnings that have not yet become available cash.
Tax preparation requires a separate look at the accounting method used for tax purposes. I would not assume that every dollar of financial statement profit translates directly into taxable income. The contractor and tax team should discuss the applicable accounting method and how it affects the timing of income. That conversation belongs in planning, not just in the rush to file a return.
Account for Retainage Before Spending the Profit
Retainage adds another layer to the cash timing problem. A portion of the contract amount may remain withheld until substantial or final completion, depending on the agreement. For illustration, that portion might be 10%, but contractors should build projections around their actual contract terms rather than a standard assumption.
The work may be finished long before retained funds become available, and collection can extend well beyond the immediate project period. Whether retainage is reportable for tax purposes depends on the accounting method and applicable treatment. For cash planning, however, the practical question remains: When can the business reasonably expect to receive it?
A forecast that treats retainage as immediately spendable cash creates a misleading picture. I want contractors to separate expected collections from amounts that remain tied up and review both regularly with their accounting team.
Trace Where the Cash Actually Went
When a contractor asks why the bank balance does not match the profit, I start with the uses and timing of cash. Slow-paying customers are one explanation. A deposit may cover the beginning of a job, but the remaining balance can still be outstanding after completion. Reviewing receivables means identifying what is unpaid, following up, and using realistic collection expectations in the forecast.
Debt payments also deserve attention. Loan principal consumes cash without reducing net profit as an operating expense. Interest and principal should be distinguished, and the tax treatment of interest reviewed with the tax team. A contractor who looks only at the income statement can overlook the cash required to repay borrowing.
Payroll and subcontractor payments may come due before customer invoices are sent or collected. That timing gap needs to be visible before the contractor commits to spending. Retainage and delayed receivables can make the gap harder to manage.
Owner distributions are another important use of funds. Withdrawals can reduce the cash available for operations and taxes without appearing as expenses on the profit and loss statement. Before approving a distribution, I would review upcoming obligations and the tax projection. Available cash should not automatically be treated as cash available to withdraw.
Turn Tax Projections Into a Cash Plan
A rolling 13-week cash flow forecast gives contractors a practical framework for connecting collections with planned expenses and tax obligations. Include expected customer payments, payroll, subcontractors, vendors, debt payments, and owner distributions. Show retainage according to its expected release, not simply because it appears in the books. Update the forecast as circumstances change.
Pair that forecast with a separate tax reserve account. Its purpose is to hold money designated for taxes, not to serve as a general savings account or a convenient source of operating funds. Discuss the reserve amount with the tax professional and revisit it alongside the projection.
Review accounts receivable and retainage regularly so unpaid balances and delayed releases do not disappear from attention. Monitor estimated tax payments as part of the same process. The goal is to connect the projected obligation with both a payment timetable and a realistic source of cash.
Before major equipment purchases or owner distributions, consult the tax team. Tax planning should consider the expenditure, its effect on the projection, and the cash needed afterward. A spending decision should not leave the business unable to fund its next tax payment.
Recognize Warning Signs and Act Early
Using payroll tax funds for vendor payments, delaying estimated taxes, or relying on deposits from new projects to finance existing jobs are warning signs that deserve immediate attention. They should prompt a review of the forecast, collections, and spending commitments.
My message to contractors is straightforward: tax preparation tells you what must be reported, while planning and projections help you prepare for what comes next. Profit matters, but protecting the cash to pay taxes requires deliberate, ongoing attention.
About the Author
Lynn Karam
Founder and CEO of LEK Management Inc.
Related
dreamstime_m_45719380
dreamstime_m_16132081

